Ernst Jünger and the Libyan revolution

Chunks of Heliopolis and Eumeswil dealing with smartphones, language and power meet up with the Gaddafis.

Arthur Ditchfield, The Casbah and the Ravine of the Centaur, Algiers (1873), at the <a href='http://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O125738/oil-painting-the-casbah-and-the-ravine/'>V&A</a>

Arthur Ditchfield, The Casbah and the Ravine of the Centaur, Algiers (1873), at the V&A

There’s a rather strange blog out there which tells us that “Ernst Jünger‘s life and later works can function as excellent road maps to freedom and fulfilment in the modern world.” One of their remarkable ideas is that Steve Jobs was working along the lines of a Jünger blueprint when he came up with the iPhone 4. In a recent post they quote from a description of the phonophore in Jünger’s Heliopolis (1949): a smart wireless pod which offers P2P connectivity for the inhabitants of “workers’ world” as well as a constant flow of information between these worker-ant super-men and centralised servers, providing them with a comprehensive range of range of services (media, financial, geo, etc) and the bureacracy with the user inputs required to administer mobocracy effectively.

Given what’s happening in North Africa and Jünger’s interest in communications technology and government, I guess a post on his Eumeswil (1977) is on the way. This pseudo-novel describes a future dystopian city-state imbued with a multitude of motifs from several millennia of Mediterranean-inspired political culture and ruled by the Condor from his eyrie, the Casbah. Like Atlantis it is located along North Africa’s Atlantic coast, and like Plato’s fiction it serves as a springboard for a discussion of power and government (which of course may not prevent loons from looking for it in several thousand years times).

Among the profuse notes made by Martin Venator, bartender-historian to the dictator, are descriptions of the strategies adopted the Domo, the head of the dictator’s security apparatus, to defeat rebellions by the quasi-democratic Tribunes. So (trans Joachim Neugroschel):

[T]he Domo wanted law students to master language as a logical instrument in order to be able to pass judgements: nothing is further from his mind than aesthetic or even artistic sentiments, with the exception of music.

Tyranny must value a sound administration of justice in private matters. This … increases its political authority … which rests on equality, to which tyranny sacrifices freedom. Tyranny is intent on overall leveling, which makes it akin to rule by the people. Both structures produce similar forms. They share a distaste for elites that nurture their own language and recognize themselves in it; poets are even hated.

Monoculturalism was standard 20th century socialist/fascist fare, and so I imagine Seif El Islam Gaddafi was reaffirming his progressive outlook and popular roots rather than suggesting a diglossic divide between ruler and ruled when he announced that his ramble to the people on Sunday would be “in Libyan dialect” (first heard @ Al Jazeera @ 1:00 AM, refuted here (via)). On the other hand, Mubarak and Ben Ali’s marketing was straightforward conservative-authoritarian, which might explain why the former stuck with Modern Standard Arabic until the end, and why the latter’s stated intention of using Darija as the axe fell seemed so bizarre.

To Venator’s regret the popular language is that inherited from the liberal tyranny:

In a period of decline, when it was considered glorious to have helped destroy one’s own nation, the roots of language were, not surprisingly, likewise pruned, above all in Eumeswil. Loss of history and decay of language are mutual determinants; the Eumenists championed both. They felt called upon to defoliate language on the one hand and to gain prestige for slang on the other hand. Thus, down below they robbed the populace of language and, with it, poetry, on the pretext that they were facilitating speech; while on the heights they presented their “mugs.”

The assault on evolved language and on grammar, on script and signs, is part of the simplification that has gone down in history as a cultural revolution…

The result is a disconnect between the policeman and the policed:

The Domo’s meticulous use of language contrasts strangely with the way it is routinely mangled in Eumeswil. Hackneyed phrases are all that we hear–as well worn as pennies tossed to beggars; and, indeed, they come more from academics than from the harbor or the market. This has not always been so; the farmer, the artisan, the hunter, the soldier, the crook knew how to animate powerful images.

The fellah period has made a clean sweep of such talents. Eumenists of Sperling’s and Kessmüller’s cast have done their bit. The goal was the annihilation of correct language. “Le style, c’est l’homme“–this notion was revoked; intellectual rank was no longer to be identified by a mastery of language. The result is a banal chitchat defective in both its heights and its depths.

To be sure, there were errors in calculation. Even in times when there are no cabinetmakers left, one still distinguishes the well-built armoire, or even a planed board, from all the others. Similarly, when elites have grown rare or shrunk down to a few individuals, the clear, unadulterated word convinces the uneducated man–indeed, precisely him, the non-miseducated man. He senses–and this puts his mind at ease–that the ruler still observes rules despite his power. Caesar non supra grammaticos. A solace in periods of decline.

It would have been cool to have been able to compare Gaddafi’s interior minister Abdul Fattah Younis with the Domo, but it doesn’t sound like we’re going to be seeing him again. Vis-à-vis the Condor, one of Gaddafi’s errors was perhaps that he talked rather too much. Jünger creates a far greater sense of awe around his dictator by having him speak through his minions (who can always be fed to the lions if the public doesn’t appreciate the message). Afaik the only time we get a hint of the Condor’s words or intonation is near the beginning:

When I, like anyone having business in his proximity, was introduced to the Condor, he picked out his name for me. “Manuel, Manuelo, Emanuelo”–depending on the phonetic context. His way of distinguishing and modulating deepens the effect when he addresses people. In the agora, the how is even more important than the what, the delivery more powerful than the facts that it can alter, indeed create.

I guess that the stress on presentation is one thing that won’t change in Libya, whether the Gaddafi clan are succeeded by liberal republicans or, breaking with Eumeswil, by a slightly less deranged military government in Tripolitania with in Cyrenaica an Egyptian or Iranian client.

Similar posts

Published
Last updated 18/12/2018

This post pre-dates my organ-grinding days, and may be imported from elsewhere.

Apple Inc. (1): Apple Inc.

Arabic (2):

Atlantis (2): Atlantis is a fictional island mentioned within an allegory on the hubris of nations in Plato's works Timaeus and Critias, where it represents the antagonist naval power that besieges "Ancient Athens", the pseudo-historic embodiment of Plato's ideal state in The Republic.

Cyrenaica (1): Cyrenaica ( SY-rə-NAY-ik-ə; Latin: Cyrenaica [Provincia], Koine Greek: Κυρηναϊκή [ἐπαρχία], translit.

Diglossia (2):

Egypt (9):

Ernst Jünger (2): Ernst Jünger was a highly decorated German soldier, author, and entomologist who became publicly known for his World War I memoir Storm of Steel.

Fascism (14):

German literature (7):

Hosni Mubarak (1): Muhammad Hosni El Sayed Mubaraksˈsæjjed moˈbɑːɾɑk], Muḥammad Ḥusnī Sayyid Mubārak; born 4 May 1928) is a former Egyptian military and political leader who served as the fourth President of Egypt from 1981 to 2011. Before he entered politics, Mubarak was a career officer in the Egyptian Air Force.

IPhone (1):

Jamahiriya (2):

Libya (3): Libya; Arabic: ليبيا‎,), officially the State of Libya, is a country the Maghreb region in North Africa, bordered by the Mediterranean Sea to the north, Egypt to the east, Sudan to the southeast, Chad and Niger to the south and Algeria and Tunisia to the west.

Maghreb (2): The Maghreb (; Arabic: المغرب‎, translit.

Mediterranean Sea (73): The Mediterranean Sea is a sea connected to the Atlantic Ocean, surrounded by the Mediterranean Basin and almost completely enclosed by land: on the north by Southern Europe and Anatolia, on the south by North Africa, and on the east by the Levant.

Muammar al-Gaddafi (2): From a different spelling: This is a redirect from a title with a different spelling of the target name.

North Africa (1): The term "North Africa" has no single accepted definition.

Ochlocracy (2): Ochlocracy or mob rule is the rule of government by mob or a mass of people, or, the intimidation of legitimate authorities.

Peer-to-peer (1): Peer-to-peer computing or networking is a distributed application architecture that partitions tasks or workloads between peers.

Plato (1): Plato was a philosopher in Classical Greece and the founder of the Academy in Athens, the first institution of higher learning in the Western world.

Retro-futurism (1): From a page move: This is a redirect from a page that has been moved.

Saif al-Islam Muammar Al-Gaddafi (1):

Socialism (8):

Sociolinguistics (2):

Steve Jobs (1): Steven Paul Jobs was an American business magnate and investor.

Totalitarianism (3):

Tripolitania (1): Tripolitania or Tripolitana is a historic region and former province of Libya. Tripolitania was a separate Italian colony from 1927 to 1934.

Tunisia (2): Tunisia is a country in the Maghreb region of North Africa, covering 165,000 square kilometres.

World War I (10):

World War II (13):

Zine El Abidine Ben Ali (1): Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, commonly known as Ben Ali, is a Tunisian former politician who served as President of Tunisia from 1987 until his ousting in 2011.


Comments

    1. Simon Friedrich
      February 24th 2011 13:03

      Dear Trebots,

      I’m glad you found my “rather strange” blog!

      To clarify the context of your words: Steve Jobs has certainly never heard of Ernst Jünger. The connection, if there is one, is in the other direction; in such novels as Eumeswil, Heliopolis and Glass Bees, EJ foresaw the advent of titans like him as well as the general line of their technical inventions. ie phonophore/iPhone4 – of course the significance here is not in the phonetic similarity (which is merely coincidental) but rather in the functional ones.

      Cheers,

      Simon

    2. Simon Friedrich
      February 24th 2011 13:17

      By the way, a blog on revolutions in North Africa using Eumeswil and the Condor as material was indeed being considered. Glad you brought it up – I might do it still.

      But it would be more poignant in a year or less, when the turnarounds promised by the new regimes do not pan out as promised and it is oppression as usual, just by a new master.

      From Eumeswil, a few quotes on Jünger’s view on political change:

      “Seen politically, systems follow one another, each consuming the previous one. They live on ever-bequeathed and ever-disappointed hope, which never entirely fades. Its spark is all that survives, as it eats its way along the blasting fuse. For this spark, history is merely an occasion, never a goal.”

      “The political trend is always to be observed, partly as a spectacle, partly for one’s own safety. The liberal is dissatisfied with regime; the anarch passes through their sequence – as inoffensively as possible – like a suite of rooms. This is the recipe for anyone who cares more about the substance of the world than its shadow – the philosopher, the artist, the believer.”

      “If Zerrwick can pick at the Condor, he will stop at nothing. As a nihilistic conjuror, he pulls what he likes from his top hat: liberty caps or crowns and scepters. I mention this because it fits in with a New Year’s mood that is spreading through the tyranny. Each man nurtures his own ideal, which barely makes it past the surging of jubilation. I once thought of a hundred-year calendar with the journée des dupes as one of the recurring red-letter days.
      The anarch nurtures no expectations. He stakes on no one but himself. Basically, people remain pied pipers, whatever melodies they play to introduce themselves. And as for the rats – that is a chapter unto itself.”

      Simon

    3. Trebots
      February 24th 2011 16:02

      Ah! where would we be without the rats (and the cats and the dogs)! “Strange” is actually something a compliment here – and I believe one of the few ways that visitors can be persuaded to click through.

      The guy who gave me Eumeswil pitched Jünger to me as a cross between Pynchon and Nostradamus. I’m not so sure re the latter, but the book was certainly a reading experience as fearful as the densest TP. When I’ve gathered courage I’ll have a go at Heliopolis, which I may try in German – the Eumeswil translation left me uneasy.

    4. Simon Friedrich
      February 25th 2011 13:30

      You might be thankful for the Eumeswil in English once you get into Heliopolis in German! It is perhaps even more dense – but in the end I find Eumeswil has more to give.

      Never heard the Nostradamus comparison before, but Jünger certainly made remarkable predictions regarding technology in Heliopolis and Glass Bees.

      BTW, a fantastic read is his brother Friedrich Georg Jünger´s book The Failure of Technology, which is translated in English. A remarkably deep understanding of technology´s limits and dangers.

    5. Trebots
      February 25th 2011 21:14

      Despise me if you will, but I may save the brother for my next incarnation. I’ll still have a go at Heliopolis, though. Promise!

    6. kalebeul » New translation of Jünger Der Waldgang
      December 3rd 2013 23:20

      […] here. I haven’t read it but waded my way through Heliopolis (more or less contemporaneous) and Eumeswil (mid-70s) in the original ages ago, when I was using German in professional wars against some […]

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *